Tricia Helfer found out that Anna Pigeon had been renewed from a flurry of texts she had slept through one morning. USA Network ordered a second season on 7 October, two days before the first-season finale. A few days later the Canadian actress talked to Meg McCarthy of CherryPicks about her character, grief, her career and the fans of Battlestar Galactica.
Feast or famine
McCarthy opens by praising a career that has taken in almost every genre. Helfer says she tends to think about everything she has not done yet. There have been slow years, when you wonder whether it is all over. Right now she is going from one job to the next, but the fear of a year without work never quite leaves. The business lacks security, she says, and that can mess with your head. McCarthy recalls her first day at drama school, when a teacher drew a line going up and down and told the class that this would be their career, however talented they were.
Too old for one part, too young for the next
Helfer sees female characters becoming more rounded. She was discussing it recently with Tracy Spiridakos, who plays Anna Pigeon, a flawed character with many sides. That is the kind of part she wants. She went through a lean patch, she explains, because Hollywood does not always know what to do with an actress as she gets older: too old for what she used to play, not yet old enough for the female version of the grizzled captain. She would rather be challenged than play the cold-hearted lawyer one more time.
Molly, psychiatrist and big sister
In the series, based on Nevada Barr's mystery novels, Helfer plays Molly, Anna's older sister, a psychiatrist in New York. Anna, a park ranger, lost her husband in horrific circumstances that were never resolved, and took refuge in the national parks. Molly reads people for a living. With her sister, she has taken on the roles of big sister and therapist at once. Episode nine finally put the two of them on screen together, and there Molly starts to learn that she cannot be the psychiatrist and the sister at the same time; she has to know which one Anna needs, and when.
There are nineteen novels, and not all of them are optioned for each season, so she is waiting to find out which books season two will draw on. The finale goes back, with flashbacks, to the source of Anna's trauma, which gives the next season more to build on.
Keeping the heart of the book
This is not her first adaptation. In Hello Beautiful, based on Christine Handy's book Walk Beside Me, she plays a breast cancer survivor. Handy was a producer and on set, yet even so her family was changed for the screen. The same year, 2024, Helfer shot Primitive War, a war film with dinosaurs, also based on books, which she admits she has not read. You have to keep the heart of the story, she says, while accepting that a film or a series cannot expand on everything a book can.
She reads in bursts, straight through. She devoured the Game of Thrones novels and has never watched the series for fear of being disappointed. When she is shooting, though, she reads nothing at all: she stays inside the story she is telling.
No single way to grieve
Anna Pigeon is very much a show about grief. Helfer believes there is no one way through it. She remembers a friend telling her she had not grieved, because she was not crying. You may notice someone pushing things aside, or drinking too much, she says, but you cannot tell people how to grieve. Molly watches her sister run away. She has to accept that this may be what Anna needs, as long as she is not harming others or herself.
What the fans taught her
At conventions, people mostly want to talk about Battlestar Galactica, in which she played Number Six. She can catch herself thinking it is just television, that nobody is curing cancer. Fans remind her otherwise when they tell her the show helped them through something hard. Storytelling goes back to cave walls, she says, and in an increasingly isolated world it brings people together, as at Dragon Con, which she had attended a month or so earlier.
Next up: Devour
She is currently shooting Devour, a body horror film she describes as very psychological. She plays Louisa, a woman learning to accept parts of herself she has pushed down her whole life. You want to cheer her on, but it comes at a cost to other people. If she does her job right, she says, audiences will feel some empathy for her too.
© Video: CherryPicks